If you want to experience world-class Islamorada fishing without the high price tag of a private charter, theCaptain Michael is the local gold standard. Operating out of the famous Robbie’s Marina, this 65-foot deep-sea vessel offers a social, affordable, and high-action way to get out on the reef.
Location: Mile Marker 77.5 (Robbie’s Marina), Islamorada, FL
Pricing: $75 – $100 per person (Ages 12 & under often discounted)
Capacity: Up to 40 anglers
Vibe: Professional, family-friendly, and high-energy.
Contact: (305) 664-8070 |captainmichaelfishing.com
The Captain Michael runs three distinct trips daily, allowing you to choose the timing that fits your schedule (and your sleep preference):
Trip Type | Time | Price | Best For
Morning Trip | 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM | $100 | Early birds and peak fish activity.
Afternoon Trip | 2:30 PM – 6:30 PM | $75 | Sunset views and a relaxed pace.
Night Trip | 7:30 PM – 12:30 AM | $100 | Targeting nocturnal Snapper and cooler air.
One of the best parts of a "party boat" (or head boat) experience is that they handle the logistics. Your ticket covers:
Gear: Rods, reels, and all the tackle you’ll need.
Bait: Fresh bait provided for the duration of the trip.
Licensing: You donot need to buy a separate Florida fishing license; you are covered under the boat’s master permit.
Fish Cleaning: The mates will fillet or steak your catch back at the dock for a small tip/fee.
The Captain Michael typically targets the local reefs and wrecks. Depending on the season and time of day, you can expect to reel in:
Snapper: Yellowtail, Mangrove, and Mutton (the local favorites).
Grouper: Red, Black and Gag (seasonally dependent).
Mackerel: Kingfish and Cero.
Bonus: You might also encounter Porgy, Amberjack, or even the occasional shark.
Check-In: Arrive at least30 minutes before departure to secure your spot and get your gear.
What to Bring: Pack a small cooler with snacks and drinks (no glass allowed). Don't forget polarized sunglasses, a hat, and plenty of sunscreen.
Cook Your Catch: Once the mates clean your fish, you can take your fresh fillets to several nearby waterfront restaurants that will "cook your catch" for you right on the spot.
The Stern Advantage: If you have a preferred spot on the boat, show up early; however, the crew often utilizes a "rotation" system to ensure everyone gets a fair shot at the best fishing spots.
Address
77522 Overseas Hwy
Phone
(305) 664-8070Website
Visit Website
“Luxury private boat charters, sandbar days, snorkeling, island hopping, sunset cruises, and custom Key West water adventures.”
“Sombrero Reef snorkel trips and sunset eco history tours from Marathon.”
