Payfair Supermarket – Tavernier’s Hidden Gem

🕒 Open Daily: 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM

Located just minutes from Islamorada, Payfair Supermarket is a beloved, family-owned neighborhood grocery store known for quality, convenience, and old-school charm. Whether you’re grabbing groceries for the week or a quick bite on the go, Payfair delivers a true local Keys experience.

⭐ What They’re Known For:

• Famous Deli Subs: Made fresh with Boar’s Head meats sliced to order. Locals rave about the Cuban and Italian subs—call ahead and they’ll have it ready when you walk in!

• Top-Quality Meats: Butcher-cut selections and fresh seafood perfect for grilling or a day out on the water.

• Local Vibe: A clean, friendly spot with quick service, cold beer, and shelves stocked with everyday essentials.

Perfect For:

• Visitors staying in the Keys who want a quick, reliable market.

• Locals looking for unbeatable deli sandwiches.

• Anglers and boaters grabbing provisions before hitting the water.