Profile
🕒 Open Daily: 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Located just minutes from Islamorada, Payfair Supermarket is a beloved, family-owned neighborhood grocery store known for quality, convenience, and old-school charm. Whether you’re grabbing groceries for the week or a quick bite on the go, Payfair delivers a true local Keys experience.
⭐ What They’re Known For:
Famous Deli Subs: Made fresh with Boar’s Head meats sliced to order. Locals rave about the Cuban and Italian subs—call ahead and they’ll have it ready when you walk in!
Top-Quality Meats: Butcher-cut selections and fresh seafood perfect for grilling or a day out on the water.
Local Vibe: A clean, friendly spot with quick service, cold beer, and shelves stocked with everyday essentials.
Perfect For:
Visitors staying in the Keys who want a quick, reliable market.
Locals looking for unbeatable deli sandwiches.
Anglers and boaters grabbing provisions before hitting the water.
Map
Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.
Sorry, unable to load the Maps API.
